| • PM Motor controller |
Which kind of motor is best solution for EV,AC or DC?
DC Motors
There are four main types of DC motor, namely permanent
magnet, series, shunt and seperately excited. The latter three
all use field coils in the stator (the part which doesn't
move) to generate a magnetic field for the rotor to spin in,
and their name simply refers to the way the field coils are
wired with respect to the rotor coils. All four types use a
commutator to control which rotor coils are energised at any
given time in order to maintain rotation, and it is enough
just to apply a DC voltage across their terminals to get the
motor to spin, so they are relatively easy to control.
Currently series DC are the most economical and commonly
used type of motor in electric vehicles. Being a
tried-and-tested technology, they are actually quite good –
with efficiencies up to 90% and only needing servicing every
100,000kms or so. However using a commutator is restrictive
and a source of inefficiency. Also, with series DC motors
regenerative braking is very difficult to do (in fact, you
basically have to operate the motor as a sepex DC motor).
Regen can increase your range by 10-20%, so is quite
valuable. |

Permanent Magnet DC Motor

DC Motor with wound
stator
|
Brushless DC Motors
In a brushless DC motor (BLDC), the rotor has permanent
magnets and the stator has an electronically-controlled
rotating field, using sensors (rotary encoders or back-EMF) to
detect rotor position. As such they have no commutator, and
tend to be more efficient and more powerful than commutated
motors. They do require a more complicated motor controller,
although as the technology matures and costs come down they
are becoming increasingly popular, particularly for smaller
motors.
The main disadvantage for EV use is the cost of the large
permanent magnet(s) required for the rotor, and the added
expense of the speed controller. Unfortunately, at present
there are no economically viable BLDC options available for EV
use. ZEVA is hoping to change this in the near future. |

Brushless DC Motor ("in-runner"
type)
|
AC Motors
Although there are a variety of motors which will run on AC
power, for EV use it usually refers to AC induction.
The operation of induction motors is a somewhat difficult
concept to grasp at first. Basically they use a rotating
magnetic field in the stator to induce a magnetic field in the
rotor and hence a current to flow in the rotor's coils. The
rotor coils actually just loop around on themself - they are
not explicitly powered. The induced field in the rotor tried
to stay aligned with the rotating field of the stator, so it
turns to chase the stator's field. Due to loads on the motor,
the rotor's field is forced to rotate slightly slower than the
stator's field (if it kept up exactly, there would be no
difference in the fields and hence no torque). Three phase induction motors are very common for industrial
use because they are highly efficient and reliable. These same
advantages apply for electric vehicle use, except for the
added complication that a variable-speed inverter is required
to control the AC motor from a DC power supply (the battery).
These are a relatively expensive piece of hardware. Although
they do include regenerative braking and are generally more
efficient, AC systems currently cost about twice as much as
series DC. |

AC Induction Motor
|
Conclusion Currently, the most economical (and indeed common) option for
electric vehicles is series DC technology. However, it is likely
that all commutated motors will be phased out over the next decade
or two, since a commutator's functionality can be replaced by clever
electronics (which is getting cheaper every day), and with improved
reliability and efficiency. At present, AC induction and permanent
magnet brushless DC are the best technologies available, with
efficiencies up to 98%, silent operation, and almost never requiring
any servicing. They each have various advantages and disadvantages
over one another. It will be interesting to see which one becomes
the new standard in the years to
come. |